Security Review of Popular Messaging Apps: Signal, WhatsApp, GroupMe, and SMS

Security Challenge

Messaging apps are part of our daily lives — whether it's texting friends, coordinating with family, or sharing personal thoughts. But not all messaging apps protect your conversations in the same way. Some collect your data, others sell it to advertisers, and many don’t use strong protections to keep your messages private.

So, how do the most popular messaging apps compare? In this post, we’ll break down the privacy and security of Signal, WhatsApp, GroupMe, and regular SMS (text messaging) in simple, easy-to-understand terms. We'll also explore how your choice of app can affect real-world scenarios — like talking about sensitive issues with people you trust.

Recommendation

Let’s consider this situation:
Maria is a college student who needs to talk with her two sisters about something very personal — a disagreement in the family that's affecting everyone emotionally. She doesn’t want to talk on the phone, and she’s worried about someone else gaining access to the conversation.

Maria is concerned about online threats like hackers, surveillance, and data tracking, but her biggest concern is more personal: her ex-boyfriend, who is still connected to one of her sisters and has a history of snooping. He once guessed her password to get into her old email account, and she knows he wouldn’t hesitate to open someone’s phone if it was left unlocked. She’s even read stories about people hijacking phone numbers to gain access to messaging apps.

Maria needs a messaging app that keeps her conversations safe — even if someone gets access to her or her sisters’ phones, or tries to hijack a number. She wants:

Strong encryption so only she and her sisters can read the messages
No message previews on the lock screen
An app that won’t reveal anything unless unlocked with Face ID, fingerprint, or a PIN
Protection against SIM hijacking or account takeovers
A platform that doesn’t use or sell message content or metadata for ads

She’s looking for a messaging app that respects her privacy and puts up serious barriers to curious exes, data-hungry companies, and digital snoops alike.

Let’s break down how the top messaging apps protect someone like Maria — and what to look out for.

Signal

Signal is operated by the Signal Technology Foundation, a nonprofit based in California. It exists solely to provide private, secure communication — not to make money from users. Signal is funded by donations and grants, not advertising or data collection. It follows U.S. and European privacy laws including CCPA, ECPA, and GDPR.

Encryption Protocol: Signal Protocol (end-to-end encrypted)

Strengths:

Built specifically for privacy and funded by donations — no ads or trackers
Uses state-of-the-art encryption and collects minimal metadata (just your phone number and last active time)
Open-source, meaning anyone can inspect the code for transparency and safety
Operates under strong privacy laws like GDPR and CCPA

Weaknesses:

Requires a phone number for setup (though future updates aim to change this)
Some users may not be familiar with it, so adoption may be a barrier
Slightly more effort to onboard friends or family who haven’t used it before

For Maria, Signal is the most secure and private choice — especially when the conversation is deeply personal. If her sisters are willing to try something new, Signal gives peace of mind that no one — not even the app itself — can see what they’re discussing.

WhatsApp is owned by Meta, the company behind Facebook and Instagram. It uses the Signal Protocol for encrypting messages and calls, but collects a lot of metadata — including your contacts, location, device type, and how often you message. Meta uses this metadata across its ecosystem to build advertising profiles.

Encryption Protocol: Signal Protocol (end-to-end encrypted)

Strengths:

Uses strong encryption to protect message content
Very popular and easy to use — chances are, Maria’s sisters already have it installed
Offers useful features like voice calls, media sharing, and cloud backup

Weaknesses:

Collects and shares user metadata with Meta for advertising and analytics
Not all parts of the app are open-source — only the encryption layer is
Backups are not encrypted by default, which can expose past conversations if enabled

Meta’s vast infrastructure and support make WhatsApp reliable, but privacy comes with trade-offs. For Maria, WhatsApp is a convenient second-best option — her messages are safe from outside reading, but Meta still sees who she talks to and when.

GroupMe

GroupMe is owned by Microsoft, a large technology company with a mixed record on privacy. Unlike Signal and WhatsApp, GroupMe does not use end-to-end encryption. Messages are stored on Microsoft’s servers and may be accessible to the company or law enforcement. GroupMe operates under U.S. laws such as CCPA, ECPA, and the CLOUD Act, which allow for government data requests.

Encryption Protocol: None

Strengths:

Very simple and familiar interface
Allows messaging without needing everyone’s phone number (just email or username)
Backed by a trusted and stable company (Microsoft)

Weaknesses:

No encryption means Microsoft could read your messages
Not built with privacy in mind — it’s meant for casual use like school groups or event planning
Data is stored on the cloud and could be accessed by Microsoft or shared with third parties

For Maria, GroupMe is not a good fit. While it’s convenient and low-effort, it offers no protection if someone outside the family were to try and access their conversation.

SMS (Text Messaging)

SMS (regular text messaging) is provided by your mobile carrier, like AT&T, Verizon, or T-Mobile. It does not use any encryption, meaning messages can be read or stored by your carrier. Carriers are allowed to share metadata and message content with law enforcement under laws like CALEA and the Telecommunications Act.

Encryption Protocol: None

Strengths:

Built into every phone — no downloads or setup needed
Universal compatibility

Weaknesses:

Least secure option — carriers can read and retain all messages
Messages are vulnerable to interception or surveillance
Metadata and content may be stored long term and provided to authorities

For Maria, SMS is the riskiest choice. Even though it’s easy, it leaves her most exposed if privacy is a concern.

How They Compare (Simple Table)

Closing Thoughts

For Maria — and anyone who values their privacy — Signal is the best option. It’s secure, private, and run by a nonprofit with no incentive to collect your data. It may take a bit of effort to get started, but the peace of mind is worth it.

WhatsApp offers strong encryption and is incredibly easy to use, but its connection to Meta means that your activity data isn’t fully private. It’s a practical choice if you need quick access and your contacts already use it.

GroupMe and SMS are best left for casual, low-risk conversations. They don’t offer the protections needed for sensitive topics.

Tip: The messaging app you use shapes your digital footprint. Choose a platform that works for you — and protects you.

Elevate Secure

Search This Blog